TRACE THE
FAILURE
Buildings · Evidence and investigation

They dug right beside it.
Who had to protect it?

On November 11, 2026, a 96-year-old building on Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn fell into the construction pit next door, where a crew was digging a new building's foundation. New York's building code says whoever has a hole dug must protect the building beside it. Nobody has said yet why this one fell.

Follow the evidence
Aerial view of a collapsed building's rubble in the construction pit next door, with firefighters on the pit floor, a yellow excavator, a fire truck's aerial ladder and the row of buildings still standing beside it.
The collapsed building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, in the excavation next door. Frame from ABC7 New York's aerial video, November 11, 2026. Not AI-generated.
THE COMPANION FILMBrooklyn Building Collapse: They Dug Right Beside It Watch episode 10:27

What happened

At about 4:01 p.m. on Wednesday, November 11, 2026, the FDNY got a call for a collapse at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn. Briefing, 3:30 The three-story building on the corner of Bedford Avenue had fallen into the construction site next door, where a crew was digging. FDNY Chief of Department John Esposito described “the complete collapse of a three-story multiple dwelling into the construction site excavation next door.” Briefing, 7:43

Two people were killed and seventeen were hurt, by the FDNY’s count at the 8:16 p.m. briefing that night, and seven of the nineteen were children. Briefing, 4:30 Rescuers searched the rubble through the night. The next day, Mayor Zohran Mamdani said eight people had died, two of them children, and 18 were hurt. Six died at the scene and two in the hospital, and two of the dead were construction workers. Gothamist

New York’s building code puts the duty to protect a building beside a dig on whoever causes the excavation. Building Code 3309.4 Nobody has said whether that duty was met here, and investigators haven’t named a cause. ENR

You may have read that the city ordered work stopped on the lot next door. It did, on March 20, 2026, during the demolition of the old building there, and it lifted the order on May 8. The digging on Wednesday was a separate job, under permits the city’s records date to September 9.

This story is still developing, and this article reflects the public record as of about 6 p.m. EST on Thursday, November 12, 2026. The FDNY ended its search that afternoon, and officials say there are no more victims. ABC7 live updates

Watch the episode

The film goes through the city’s own record pages for the lot next door, with the officials’ words from the briefing that night and a 3D explainer of how a building beside a hole is meant to be held up. It has no AI-generated images: the footage is real news video, and the 3D block and diagrams are illustrations built from the city’s tax map and records, not an official reconstruction.

Update, November 12, 2026: this video was made on the night of the collapse, when the FDNY’s count was two dead, so that’s the number you’ll hear in it. The next day, Mayor Zohran Mamdani said eight people had died, two of them children, and 18 were hurt.

The stop-work order

1321 Flatbush went up in 1930. It had three stories, with a store on the ground floor and four apartments upstairs. City land-use records (PLUTO); certificate of occupancy, 1960 Right along its side is the lot at 2625 Bedford Avenue, where a one-story building from 1933 stood until spring 2026. A local state lawmaker told NY1 it used to be a day care center for seniors. CNN live updates

In January 2026, an application went in to replace that building with a nine-story building with 64 apartments. The city’s records list the application’s status as “Objections,” and it hasn’t been approved. DOB NOW job filings Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said the plan the city did approve is for a three-story building. CBS New York The city’s filings and permits for the lot list the owner as W6 Facility X. LLC. DOB NOW job filings

First the old building had to come down. The city issued the demolition permit on March 13, 2026, and its permit records list N Tech Design of America as the permit holder. DOB NOW approved permits Five days later, someone called 311, the city’s complaint line, to say the demolition wasn’t safe and debris was flying everywhere. DOB complaint 3A53231

Two days after that, on March 20, an inspector found that “full demolition had started” without the overhead protection the approved plans called for over the neighboring properties. The inspector’s order read: “Stop all demolition work. Provide overhead protection for adjoining properties as required.” DOB complaint 3A53231

Inspectors came back on April 23 and compared new photos with the ones from March 20, when a one-story building still stood. The inspector wrote that the respondent “unlawfully continued work while on notice of a stop work order,” and that “The 1 story building was Completely fully demo.” DOB complaint 3A58886

The city’s violation records name N Tech Design of America as the respondent on both violations. The company admitted both at hearings and paid $2,500 for the first and $10,000 for the second, $12,500 in all. OATH/ECB 39552071X; OATH/ECB 39553409Z In an email to CBS New York, the demolition contractor put the problems down to a “missing fire extinguisher” and “house keeping issues,” and said it only did the demolition, months earlier, and not the digging on Wednesday. CBS New York

On May 8, the Buildings Department lifted the stop-work order. Its note reads: “Demo Completed. Civil penalty Paid.” DOB complaint 3A53231 The order covered the demolition, and it ended six months before the collapse.

The dig was a separate job

The digging was for the new building’s foundation. Under the new-building job, the plans for holding back the sides of the hole, called support of excavation, were approved on March 22, 2026, and the foundation and earthwork plans on June 3. The city’s filing records give September 9 as the first permit date for both. DOB NOW job filings Engineering News-Record (ENR), a construction trade magazine that reviewed the permits, reports that the Buildings Department issued the earthwork and support-of-excavation permits that day. ENR

According to ENR, both permits list Townhouse Builders as contractor, and the support-of-excavation filing lists an engineer with LMW Engineering Group LLC, of Linden, New Jersey. ENR The city’s filings name the same firm as the applicant for the foundation and support-of-excavation plans. DOB NOW job filings

ENR also reports that the excavation was “permitted to extend 14 ft below grade,” and that the job required special inspection of the sheeting, shoring and bracing that hold back its sides. ENR We couldn’t check the depth in the city’s public permit data, and the city’s online permit system was down when we tried, early on November 12.

On Wednesday afternoon, that was the work going on. “There were construction workers actively working when the collapse occurred,” Esposito said. Tigani added: “The type of work they were conducting was excavation work on that job site.” CBS New York; Briefing, 9:44

What holds a building up

A building’s walls carry its weight down to its foundation, and the foundation sits on soil. That soil stays put because the soil around it pushes back, including the soil under the lot next door.

Dig that soil out and the ground under the neighbor’s foundation loses its support from the side. It can slide into the hole. Federal safety rules call that a cave-in: soil separating from the side of an excavation and moving into it suddenly, “either by falling or sliding.” 29 CFR 1926.650 A building standing on that ground can sink or lean with it.

This is general engineering, and investigators haven’t tied it to 1321 Flatbush. It’s why New York’s building code has rules for digging beside a building.

Who had to protect it

The code puts the job on whoever has the hole dug. Whenever soil or foundation work happens, it says, “the person who causes such to be made shall, at all times during the course of such work and at his or her own expense, preserve and protect from damage any adjoining structures, including but not limited to footings and foundations.” Building Code 3309.4, PDF p. 80 The duty comes with permission to enter the neighboring property to inspect it and do the work. Without that permission, the duty passes to the owner of the building next door.

If the neighbor’s foundation sits at or above the bottom of the new hole, the person causing the excavation must support that building’s weight and its sideways load “by proper foundations, underpinning, or other equivalent means.” Building Code 3309.4.1, PDF p. 80 Underpinning means building new supports under the neighbor’s foundation that reach deeper than the hole. In the pit-pier method, crews dig narrow pits under the foundation by hand and build a new pier in each. The code limits each pit to 4 feet wide, keeps open pits at least 12 feet apart, and puts the bottom of each pier at least a foot below the bottom of the excavation that will go beside it. Buildings Department slides on Building Code 1817.7, PDF pp. 41 to 42

Another way is to hold back the sides of the hole. ENR says the plan for this site listed several methods, including tangent or secant piles, shoring and bracing, and soldier piles with wood lagging. ENR Soldier piles are vertical beams, usually steel, set in the ground along the edge, typically 5 to 10 feet apart. The crew digs down a few feet at a time, commonly 4 to 5, and after each step slides timber boards, the lagging, in between the beams to hold the soil back. FHWA Geotechnical Engineering Circular 4, pp. 12 to 14 The code says supports like these must go in “as the excavation advances.” Building Code 3304.4.6, PDF p. 38

Deeper digs bring more rules. Before any excavation more than 10 feet deep, or 5 to 10 feet deep within 10 feet of a neighboring building, whoever causes it must document the condition of every adjacent building in a preconstruction survey. Building Code 3309.4.3, PDF p. 80 The neighboring owners must get written notice at least 10 days ahead. Building Code 3304.3.2, PDF p. 34 While the digging goes on, any building closer to the edge than the hole is deep has to be monitored. Building Code 3309.4.4, PDF p. 81 A dig permitted to go 14 feet, as ENR reports, falls under those rules.

Under the code, the survey of the building next door is the job of whoever has the hole dug.

YOUR ANSWER

Should the city have to check the building next door before anyone is allowed to dig beside it? Yes or no? Tell us in the comments under the video on YouTube.

What we don’t know yet

We don’t know what was in the ground on Wednesday: how deep the hole had gotten, what was holding its sides, or whether those rules were followed. We haven’t seen the site’s plans.

1321 Flatbush’s own city record shows no complaint about the work next door before November 11, 2026, and no structural violations. DOB complaints for 1321 Flatbush; DOB violations for 1321 Flatbush As of late November 11, ENR reported, investigators hadn’t determined whether the excavation or its supports contributed to the collapse. ENR The Buildings Department says it has opened a full investigation with law enforcement and will look at all aspects of the building and of the construction site next door. NYC Buildings on X, 10:22 p.m.

Newsweek reports that a survey of 1321 Flatbush in March 2026, filed with the developers’ application for a nine-story building on the lot, found visible cracks in its north, west and east walls and rated the north wall, the one along the lot, as poor. Newsweek City housing records list 98 open violations at the building, from bedbugs to leaks; Isolag Realty Corporation owns it. CBS New York Those are housing violations, separate from the Buildings Department records above.

People nearby remember the sound. One man told amNY he heard “two loud bangs.” amNY Another told ABC7 he heard two loud cracking sounds before the building came down, and bricks hit his foot. ABC7 A construction worker who was hurt but survived had left the excavation pit to grab his hammer, his cousin told NBC New York. He was walking back when he heard “a loud snap,” and debris fell on him. NBC New York

1323 Flatbush Avenue, which shared a wall with the corner building, stayed standing with its side torn away, exposing “a bedroom and closets filled with clothing.” NBC New York; CBS New York People from the building and the construction site were trapped. Briefing, 3:50

The first firefighters were there in under a minute, by chance. “One of our fire companies was in the neighborhood returning from another emergency and they drove upon the scene,” Esposito said. “They encountered people trapped in the adjacent building that was part of the collapse. They immediately took action and removed those people from danger.” Briefing, 7:21

More than 250 firefighters and EMS personnel worked the scene. Briefing, 3:55 They dug by hand with a drone overhead, searched with FDNY and NYPD dogs, and used buckets and vacuum trucks on the debris. NBC New York; ABC7 live updates Moving debris the wrong way can hurt the people trapped underneath or the rescuers, so every move is planned. “Every move is choreographed and critically important to patient outcomes and member safety,” said FDNY Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore. Briefing, 5:41

More than two hours after the collapse, firefighters pulled a woman alive from the wreckage. ENR A man at the scene said she was his pregnant wife, CBS New York reported. CBS New York

At the 8:16 p.m. briefing, Bonsignore gave the count, which she said was subject to change: 19 patients, two of them dead, four critical, 12 stable, and one firefighter with minor injuries. “Of those 19, seven are children.” Briefing, 4:30 Officials didn’t say who had died or whether they were adults or children, and they didn’t know how many people had been in the building. Briefing, 11:37

Esposito laid out the plan from there. Dogs would check every gap in the pile first; then crews would take the pile apart “to get down to the dirt,” which he expected to take several days. His main worry was a second collapse: “The adjoining building that remains partially intact … is always a danger.” Briefing, 7:52

The search went on through the night. That morning the mayor said he was “heartbroken that eight New Yorkers have now lost their lives.” NBC New York The FDNY ended its 24-hour search just after 4 p.m. on November 12, and officials say there are no more victims. The FDNY handed the site to the Buildings Department and the NYPD, and vacate orders cover 1323, 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Avenue, the mayor said. ABC7 live updates

At least eight households from 1321 and 1323 Flatbush were displaced. The city and the American Red Cross opened a reception center for them at the Flatbush YMCA. ABC7

The investigation

The Buildings Department and law enforcement are leading the investigation into the cause. Briefing, 2:51 The Brooklyn District Attorney’s office says it’s working with them to find out whether any criminal conduct contributed to the collapse. CBS New York On the morning of November 12, CNN reported that all permits for work on the site had been suspended. CNN live updates A Buildings Department violation record first blamed the collapse on unsafe construction at the Bedford Avenue site. The department removed that wording and told Crain’s it had been entered prematurely and was inaccurate; it says investigators haven’t determined what caused the building to fall. Patch The department has tied five entities connected to the project to about 100 other construction sites and began inspecting those sites on November 12. amNY Asked whether anyone could face criminal charges, the mayor said it was too early to say. Patch

Nobody has said yet why 1321 Flatbush fell. The story is still developing.

Eight people died, two of them children. We’re thinking of them and their families, of everyone who was hurt, and of everyone on that corner of Flatbush who lost a home.

Primary sources

We name companies as the city’s records and ENR name them. No official has said what caused the collapse. The hero image and preview artwork are frames from ABC7 New York’s aerial video of November 11, 2026, not AI images.