TRACE THE
FAILURE
AVIATION FAILURE

Same pilot, same boy.
Two crashes, eight years apart.

Stephen Hatch's Bonanza ran out of fuel over Indiana in 2003. In 2011 it came out of the clouds over Charlevoix, Michigan, at about 200 feet and stalled in a turn. Both times, the warning was already on paper. His son Austin is the only person who lived through both.

Follow the evidence
A firefighter in a yellow helmet sprays water from a green hose onto the crumpled white fuselage of a small plane lying against a garage.
The Bonanza against the garage at Charlevoix, June 24, 2011. Frame from WOOD TV8 / WPBN news video. Not AI-generated.
THE COMPANION FILMAustin Hatch Survived Two Plane Crashes. His Father Flew Both Watch episode 15:55

Why the same pilot crashed twice

Dr. Stephen Hatch, a doctor from Fort Wayne, Indiana, crashed a Beechcraft Bonanza twice with his son Austin aboard. The first crash, at Uniondale, Indiana, on September 1, 2003, killed his wife, Julie, and two of their children, Lindsay and Ian. NTSB CHI03FA291, PDF p. 1 ESPN The second, at Charlevoix, Michigan, on June 24, 2011, killed Stephen and his second wife, Kim. Austin, 16, survived again. NTSB CEN11FA417, PDF pp. 3 to 4 AnnArbor.com

In 2003 the engine ran out of fuel, and the NTSB blamed the pilot’s preflight planning. In 2011 nothing on the plane had failed. The NTSB found he stalled it at low altitude after he chose not to climb away from an approach in weather below its minimums. CHI03FA291, PDF p. 2 CEN11FA417, PDF p. 1

Both times the warning was on paper before the crash: in 2003 in his own fuel records, by our arithmetic, and in 2011 in the airport’s weather report.

Watch the episode

The film draws out both investigations: the month of fuel receipts behind the 2003 crash, and the Charlevoix cloud base falling through the evening of June 24, 2011, against the floor on the approach chart.

2003: the fuel that wasn’t there

The Hatches had spent Labor Day weekend at their lake house on Walloon Lake in northern Michigan. Stephen had held a pilot’s license since 1997 and an instrument rating, which lets a pilot fly in cloud, since March 1998. He’d bought the turbocharged Bonanza, N8018J, in March 2003. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 5 to 6 and 10

They left Boyne City at 6:12 p.m. on September 1 on an instrument flight plan, with South Bend as the backup airport. Stephen told investigators he left with 60 gallons and expected the trip to use about 35. CHI03FA291, PDF p. 4

The NTSB checked that against the plane’s fuel history. The tanks were last filled on August 1, and counting that fill and everything added after it, about 254 gallons had gone in. Over the 12.1 hours flown since, at Stephen’s own figure of 18 to 19 gallons an hour plus Beechcraft’s estimate of 4 to 8 gallons for each of 8 takeoffs, the plane would have burned between 250 and 294 gallons. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 8 to 9 Those hours include the crash flight itself, so by that math the fuel was nearly or completely gone by the end of it. Investigators found no fuel in the engine’s fuel lines or its fuel pump. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 1 to 2 and 8

Take the crash flight out and run the same numbers to the moment he left Boyne City, and by our arithmetic he had somewhere between 4 and 42 gallons, not 60. The NTSB doesn’t state that figure. The rules for flying in cloud require enough fuel to reach the destination, then the backup airport, then 45 minutes more. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 2 and 9 14 CFR 91.167

Night, cloud and no lights

On the way he switched from Smith Field, a small Fort Wayne airport, to Fort Wayne International, which has a radio beam that guides planes down to the runway in cloud. The plane didn’t descend as he expected, so he turned off the autopilot. He later said he’d been “messing around” with it. Radar had him about 400 feet above the airport, a mile and a half out, with the clouds reported at 300 feet, so he climbed away to try again. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 4, 6 and 11

Climbing through about 2,600 feet, he adjusted the mixture and the engine began to sputter. Throttle, mixture and fuel pump changes didn’t hold it. He told the controller he had a fuel problem and needed to land “ASAP,” and switching tanks didn’t restart the engine. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 4 to 5

Then nearly every light in the cockpit went out. Only the GPS and one display, which had their own lighting, stayed on. Stephen lit the instrument that shows which way is up with a flashlight from his shirt, and gave Austin, 8, in the seat beside him, another to hold on the gauge that shows climb and descent. CHI03FA291, PDF p. 5

At about 300 feet he saw road lights and aimed for a field. The plane hit a utility pole, slid across the road and caught fire. Stephen and Austin got out. Julie, 38, Lindsay, 11, and Ian, 5, did not. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 1 and 5 to 7 ESPN

What the NTSB found in 2003

The NTSB gave this probable cause:

“The pilot’s inaccurate preflight planning which resulted in an inadequate fuel supply and subsequent fuel exhaustion.” CHI03FA291, PDF p. 2

It named the low ceiling, the dark night and the utility pole as factors. Through a lawyer, Stephen said he believed the plane had malfunctioned. ESPN

Investigators also found the battery switch burned and in the off position, and listed the electrical system as shut off by accident, by the pilot. The report doesn’t say when or how that happened, or whether it explains the lights going out. Stephen told investigators that once the engine quit he had no time to secure any switches. CHI03FA291, PDF pp. 2, 5 and 8

Eight years of flying

His next logbook begins on February 28, 2004, about six months after the crash. CEN11FA417, PDF p. 4 He later married Kim Neal, they adopted each other’s children, and Austin was his best man. ESPN

On June 25, 2010, he passed an instrument proficiency check, a test of flying in cloud, and he logged 19 instrument approaches in the year after it. His logbook shows two earlier GPS flights into Charlevoix, the last in May 2009. CEN11FA417, PDF p. 4 The 2011 docket holds no FAA file on him, so the public record doesn’t say whether the FAA looked at his flying after 2003.

His plane by then was a 1975 Beechcraft A36 Bonanza, N88MN, with a Garmin GPS and a satellite weather receiver. His iPad held the Charlevoix approach chart. CEN11FA417, PDF pp. 4 to 7

2011: the clouds kept coming down

Austin committed to play basketball for Michigan in June 2011, and nine days later the family flew north to celebrate. SI They left Fort Wayne at about 5:30 p.m. on June 24 for Boyne City, which has no instrument approach: no approved way to come down through cloud and land. CEN11FA417, PDF p. 3

The weather station at nearby Charlevoix reported clouds at 1,900 feet at 5:55 p.m., and over the next 40 minutes the base dropped to 1,500 and then 1,300. At 6:48 Stephen asked for Boyne Mountain, a nearby airport with a GPS approach. Radar shows the Bonanza coming down there and climbing away again. At 7:14, Charlevoix reported most of the sky covered at 400 feet, a solid layer at 700, and less than two miles of visibility. At 7:17 he reported a missed approach at Boyne Mountain and asked for Charlevoix. CEN11FA417, PDF pp. 3 and 5 Weather information

The floor at Charlevoix

Every approach in cloud has a floor, the lowest a pilot may fly without seeing the runway. On Charlevoix’s GPS approach to runway 27, it was 438 feet above the runway. A pilot who reaches the end of the approach without the runway in sight climbs, turns left to 3,000 feet and holds over a set point. Approach chart CEN11FA417, PDF pp. 1 and 6 The latest report when he asked for Charlevoix had most of the sky covered at 400 feet, already below that floor.

Radar lost the Bonanza at 2,300 feet east of the airport, so the rest comes from people on the ground. Radar plots In the terminal, a flight instructor and his student watched drizzle start and the clouds come down within minutes. They put the base at about 200 feet, and saw the Bonanza come out of it about halfway down the runway. CEN11FA417, PDF p. 3 Witness statements

By our reading of those numbers, a plane coming out of a 200-foot cloud base was already below the 438-foot floor while still in cloud. The NTSB says only that the weather was below minimums.

The turn toward the runway

He didn’t land, and he didn’t climb away as the chart said. He added power and turned left, then right around a water tower, staying about 200 feet up, just under the clouds. On the airport’s radio he said he was “making a downwind for 27,” the leg that runs alongside the runway before the turn back to land. CEN11FA417, PDF pp. 3 to 4

A man at a nearby ballfield saw the plane pass low and slow. As it turned right toward the runway the nose came up, and “the tail dropped and fluttered.” It rolled left and fell behind the trees. CEN11FA417, PDF p. 4

That is a stall: the wing meets the air at too steep an angle, usually because the plane is too slow or the nose is too high, and stops lifting. Banking raises the speed at which a wing stalls, and the NTSB warns that steeper banks raise it “exponentially.” The usual recovery is to lower the nose, which needs height. NTSB Safety Alert 019

The Bonanza hit a yard next to the airport and came to rest partly inside an empty garage. There was no fire. The throttle was full forward. CEN11FA417, PDF pp. 4, 6 to 7 and 10 ESPN

What the NTSB found in 2011

Investigators found nothing wrong with the plane or its engine before the crash. The probable cause:

“The pilot’s inadequate airspeed while maneuvering at low altitude, which resulted in an aerodynamic stall. Contributing to the accident was the pilot’s decision to not execute a missed approach in weather conditions below minimums.” CEN11FA417, PDF p. 1

The report notes that the pilot and the surviving passenger had both been in the 2003 accident. CEN11FA417, PDF p. 4 Stephen and Kim Hatch were killed, with Ally, one of the family’s two dogs. Austin had a severe brain injury and spent two months in a coma. AnnArbor.com Michigan Athletics, 2018

Austin, and what the NTSB warned

Austin relearned how to talk and walk. He started at Michigan in 2014, made a free throw in an exhibition game against Wayne State on November 10, 2014, and scored his first official point against Coppin State on December 22. He stayed with the team through his senior year on a medical scholarship, as a student assistant. SI Michigan Athletics, 2014 Michigan Athletics, 2018 He has called his father “one of the greatest of all time.” ESPN

The NTSB kept seeing both kinds of crash. In 2013 it warned pilots about stalls at low altitude, and its alert, updated in 2015, says loss of control is the most common defining event in fatal personal-flying accidents. Safety Alert 019 In 2014 the FAA made it cheaper to fit small planes with an angle-of-attack indicator, which shows how close the wing is to stalling. NBAA In 2015 the NTSB put general aviation loss of control on its Most Wanted List and said owners should consider those indicators. NTSB Most Wanted List, 2015 In 2017 it warned about fuel: from 2011 to 2015, fuel management caused more than 50 accidents a year, and fewer than 5 percent of those investigations found a fuel system failure. Safety Alert 067

The 2015 list also described pilots like Stephen Hatch. A private pilot typically needs only a flight review every two years, an hour on the ground and an hour in the air, and compared with airline pilots, their safety depends more on their own abilities and judgment. NTSB Most Wanted List, 2015

We remember Julie, Lindsay and Ian Hatch, Kim Hatch, and Dr. Stephen Hatch.

Primary sources

Page numbers are PDF pages. The 4 to 42 gallons and the reading that the plane was below the floor while still in cloud are our arithmetic from the NTSB’s records. The hero image and preview artwork are frames of WOOD TV8 / WPBN news video of the 2011 wreck, not AI images. The film’s maps and diagrams are illustrations built from public records, and some scenes of the two flights are AI illustrations, not footage.